Beyond the Capitals: Why Andy Burnham is the Unlikely Heir to Ron Davies’s Devolution Revolution
In the autumn of 1998, as the legislation establishing the first National Assembly for Wales made its way through Parliament, the then-Secretary of State for Wales, Ron Davies, coined a phrase that would become the defining maxim of modern British constitutional politics: "Devolution is a process, not an event."
For nearly three decades, that "process" has been understood almost exclusively in one direction: the steady, incremental transfer of powers from Westminster to the national capitals of Edinburgh, Cardiff, and Belfast. It was a journey of institutional maturation—turning the Welsh Assembly from a corporate body into a fully-fledged Senedd with law-making and tax-varying powers, and expanding Holyrood’s fiscal footprint.
But standing on the former site of the Ravenscraig steelworks in Motherwell this week, Prime Minister Andy Burnham threw down a gauntlet that challenges twenty-seven years of constitutional orthodoxy. Addressing First Minister John Swinney directly, Burnham asked: "I want to push economic power out into the regions of Scotland, do you?"
Predictably, the reaction from traditional devolutionists and constitutional academics across both Scotland and Wales has been fierce. Critics, such as Cardiff University’s Professor Mark Barry, have condemned the move as "reactionary" and poor political strategy—seeing it as a reheated version of Whitehall’s old "divide and rule" playbook, bypassing national parliaments to deal directly with local councils.
Yet if we strip away the partisan suspicion between Westminster, Holyrood, and Cardiff Bay, a more compelling picture emerges. Far from betraying the spirit of 1997, Andy Burnham is acting as the truest contemporary heir to Ron Davies’s philosophy.
The Unfinished Process
When Ron Davies spoke of devolution as an ongoing process, he was articulating a fundamental democratic principle: power should not sit remotely in the hands of an administrative elite when it can be exercised closer to the people it affects. In 1997, the glaring democratic deficit in Britain was the way Whitehall governed Scotland and Wales as administrative outposts.
In 2026, however, the geography of alienation looks much more complicated. As Burnham pointed out in Motherwell, the fault lines of modern Britain are no longer just between London and the devolved nations; they run within the nations themselves.
Whether you are standing in Motherwell, where the closure of Ravenscraig tore the economic heart out of Lanarkshire, or in Burnham’s former constituency of Leigh in the old Lancashire coalfield, or in the post-industrial valleys of South Wales, the story is remarkably similar. Public transport remains heavily skewed toward the capitals. High street vacancy rates in Dundee are quadruple those in Edinburgh. A man in Glasgow still faces a life expectancy seven years shorter than his neighbour ten miles away in East Renfrewshire.
If the goal of the 1997 settlement was to ensure that communities are never again left powerless in the face of economic transition, then simply moving the seat of centralized power from Whitehall to St Andrew’s House or Cathays Park was only ever half the job. Power, as Burnham argued, "was never supposed to stop at the doors of the Scottish Parliament."
From Nation-First to Place-First
What makes Burnham’s intervention so disruptive is that he is the first Prime Minister to enter 10 Downing Street having spent a decade governing outside Westminster. His ten years as Mayor of Greater Manchester taught him that top-down, tick-box public services—whether designed by mandarins in London or civil servants in Edinburgh and Cardiff—rarely transform the fortunes of post-industrial towns.
Crucially, Burnham’s blueprint for Greater Manchester’s Live Well model didn't even come from England; it was inspired by a 2023 visit to FARE Scotland in Easterhouse, Glasgow, where bottom-up, community-led employment and youth support succeeded precisely because local people were trusted to design their own solutions.
By offering to devolve Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) employment support and UK innovation funding to Scotland—on the condition that those powers and resources are pushed right down into regional economies—Burnham is applying the Ron Davies maxim to the 21st century. He is arguing that the devolution "process" cannot be frozen in amber at the national tier while local government withers on the vine.
Bridging the Divide: Subsidiarity, Not Bypass
Of course, the anxieties of Welsh and Scottish constitutionalists cannot be dismissed lightly. For figures like Mark Barry, the frustration is obvious: how can Westminster lecture Holyrood or the Senedd on hoarding power when Whitehall still refuses to devolve major macro-economic levers, such as Welsh rail infrastructure or the Crown Estate? And how can small, fragmented local councils deliver strategic transport or industrial policy without the scale of a national parliament?
If Burnham wants his "deep devolution" agenda to succeed—and to prove that he is genuinely pursuing a "place-first, not party-first" politics—he must ensure that regional empowerment is never used as an excuse to stall national devolution.
Being the true heir to Ron Davies means recognizing that devolution is not a zero-sum game between national parliaments and local regions. It requires a two-track process:
Completing the national settlement: Trusting the Senedd and Holyrood with the macro-levers they still lack, including justice, rail infrastructure, and fairer fiscal frameworks.
Mandating the regional settlement: Establishing a shared constitutional principle across the entire UK that neither Westminster, Holyrood, nor Cardiff Bay should hoard powers that can be exercised more effectively by regional mayors, combined authorities, and local communities.
Ron Davies understood in 1998 that constitutions are living things. They either evolve to meet the material needs of citizens, or they calcify into new establishments. By challenging Edinburgh and Cardiff to let go of the reins just as he promises to unwind Whitehall, Andy Burnham isn't dismantling the devolution project—he is demanding that it finally reaches the communities it was built to serve.
No comments:
Post a Comment